Emma Watson, Florence Pugh, Saoirse Ronan, and Eliza Scalen as Meg, Amy, Jo, and Beth March in Greta Gerwig's "Little Women" (Photo Credit: Wallpaper Cave)
A few days after Christmas, I settled in for the latest screen adaptation of Little Women, this time directed by Greta Gerwig and starring Irish gem Saoirse Ronan as the iconic Jo March. Somewhat to my own surprise (book purist here), I was deeply charmed and touched. The film is an aesthetic feast between its beautiful scenery, music, and production, and it presents Louisa May Alcott’s tale of domestic trials and delights with fresh potency. At its center are sisters Meg, Jo, Beth, and Amy March, each of whom learns to chart a path forward within the confines of post-Civil War America. Generations of fans, including me, have debated each sister’s merits and most sympathetic qualities. However, on this journey through the familiar story, I found myself identifying strongly with a character who often sits more on the edge of the Marches’ family dynamic. We meet Theodore “Laurie” Laurence, here portrayed with eager, thoughtful spirit by Timothée Chalamet, as the lonely boy next door. Though he does not remain lonely, I still found his perspective a poignant reminder of the reality of loneliness, and at various points in the story, the March sisters must also face their own struggles with isolation and pain. Between Laurie’s journey and the other hardships weathered by the March family, I saw a stirring search for companionship and a true home that I think many will recognize.

Laurie first meets the March family when he escorts Jo and an injured Meg home in his carriage after a dance, and his bewilderment at the domestic scene that greets him is evident. The sisters noisily talk over each other, everyone hurries to tend Meg’s sprained ankle, and the kindly March matriarch (played winningly by Laura Dern) hands Laurie a scone as she says cheerfully, “Just call me Mother or Marmee – everyone does!” Laurie has the look of one who has stumbled upon something rare and mysterious. We find that, for him, it is indeed mysterious, as he was orphaned young and now has the company only of his reticent grandfather and a kind but stern tutor. As his friendship with the Marches grows, it’s clear that Laurie sees in them the warmth, family, and human connection he has always been without, and his hunger for it is palpable. Throughout the film, the camera often catches Laurie watching the sisters and Marmee as if trying to work them out, as if admiring their close camaraderie and wanting to find a way in.

As I watched, I felt most like Laurie in some scenes – watching from the outside and longing for the companionship seen in the sisters and Marmee. His position points to the prevalence of loneliness and reaches out a sympathetic hand to the viewer who may be in its throes. It certainly did for me. Watching the March sisters gather around a family fire, put on a play for Marmee, or wrestle each other on the floor gave rise to those familiar heartaches. My own battles with loneliness gave sharp contrast to those scenes in which the Marches gathered around their table in delighted unity. The sisters’ rocking laughter during their childhood games made me long for happy, uncomplicated family and friendship dynamics. Like Laurie, I felt like I was watching something that was out of reach for me personally.

The March sisters with Laura Dern as Marmee (Photo Credit: Wallpaper Cave)
And, in a way, the warmth and love and companionship I saw among the characters of Little Women are indeed out of reach right now. At the beginning of time, perfect harmony reigned, but then the world was broken by sin. We have the promise of a new creation coming, where hunger for love and connection will finally be satiated and all relationships will be made right again. But until then, we must fight to believe in that promise and work to be signposts of that coming fulfillment. It isn’t till the end of time that family and friendship will truly be uncomplicated by sin, that fellowship will be as warm and intimate and caring as it’s meant to be, and that no one will feel like an outsider anymore.

Little Women reflects this journey from harmony, to brokenness, and back to harmony, in how it contrasts Laurie and the sisters’ childhoods with their adulthood. One of the best directorial choices on Gerwig’s part was to unfold the narrative in flashback. The film anchors in what is the middle of Alcott’s book, when the March women and Laurie are in the grip of adult growing pains. Frequent flashbacks to their more idyllic childhoods emphasize the intrusion of hardship. We see that even though the Marches quickly enfolded Laurie as a brother, he is not immune to loneliness in other forms. He faces bitter disappointment when Jo refuses to marry him, and isolation once again ensues for a time. What’s more, even this family he idealizes also struggles mightily. The world they live in is one of poverty, war, and death. Marmee, the unconquerable backbone of the Marches, speaks of her near-constant battle with anger and sees deep grief both during and after the war. Fiercely stubborn Jo longs for independence, but near the film’s end, even she admits to desperate loneliness and a desire to be loved. From beginning to end, the story rings with yearning for home, family, and love. In a particularly poignant scene, Beth asks Jo if she misses Laurie despite her recent rejection of him, and Jo quietly answers, “I miss everything.”

Emma Watson as Meg, Saoirse Ronan as Jo, and Florence Pugh as Amy (Photo Credit: Wallpaper Cave)
It took time for me to notice it, but one understated technique in the film that lends weight to the story arc is in the camera work’s color filtering. The scenes of Meg, Jo, Beth, Amy, and Laurie’s childhoods are cast in warm, golden light, highlighting how their earlier years seem simpler and more innocent. Juxtaposed against these are the sequences of their complicated, trial-filled adulthood, which are framed in darker, grayer hues. But, as the film progresses, the flashbacks and flash-forwards grow closer together in time, building to an ending scene that is the culmination of everything the various characters have been longing for. As the family picnics on a beautiful sunlit lawn, children frolic, food is shared, and Marmee radiates love and pride. Jo has new purpose in her step, clearly content in the roles of published author and new wife (that’s how I’m reading it, anyway. Again, book purist here, guys). Notably, Laurie has reentered the March family fold by marrying Amy, who has loved him faithfully, albeit firmly, through his previous disappointment and has helped him become a better man in the process. In some of the final shots, Laurie cradles their new baby as he and Amy join the family table. No longer does he or anyone else look like an outsider, and laughter and harmony reign once again. And this scene is cast in the same golden colors used in the childhood sequences, subtly but powerfully noting that the story has come full circle, and that everyone has come home. It made me ache with sweet hope for the day that I’ll be home too.

The family reunited! (Photo Credit: JA Monkey)

Florence Pugh and Timothee Chalamet as Amy and Laurie (Photo Credit: Tumblr)
I recently had the honor of writing a review of the film adaptation of a frequently mentioned favorite book, The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society, for the online magazine Salt & Iron. I hope you enjoy! 
"The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society" (2018) (Photo Credit: Vintagemadchen)

“If books do have the power to bring people together, maybe this one will work its magic.” 

This sentiment is at the core of the recent film adaptation of Mary Ann Shaffer and Annie Barrows’s charming novel, The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society. In this story, books establish romances, unlikely friendships, and new life directions.

The film’s heroine, London-based author Juliet Ashton, finds comfort in books and her writing career in the wake of World War II. Meanwhile, hundreds of miles away, a group of friends on the island of Guernsey takes comfort from their weekly book club, which had become their saving grace when Nazis took over their island during the war. The club members have dubbed themselves “the Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society” in reference to their love of literature and to a pie made from potatoes and potato peels, which they ate at their first meeting. Food scarcity during the war made real desserts scarce, but they found humor in it when they faced it together at their meetings.

The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society opens in the aftermath of the war and focuses on Juliet Ashton’s unlikely friendship with these book club members on Guernsey. Those relationships, which grow from perseverance during hardship and a common love for books, are the lifeblood of this screen adaptation and do excellent justice to the original novel.

As a devoted fan of the book, I approached the movie with cautious optimism and was pleased overall with the result. Though the film structures the story differently than it is presented in the book, the movie retained the joyful spirit of its source material and stayed true to the book’s themes of friendship, love for reading, and the power of books to enrich the lives of individuals and communities.

Continue reading here.

“A year seems very long to wait before I see them, but remind them that while we wait we may all work, so that these hard days need not be wasted. I know they will remember all I said to them, that they will be loving children to you, will do their duty faithfully, fight their bosom enemies bravely, and conquer themselves so beautifully that when I come back to them I may be fonder and prouder than ever of my little women.” 

So wrote Mr. March to his beloved wife and daughters in Louisa May Alcott’s timeless classic, Little Women. While I’ve loved this book since childhood, I’ve been reminded this week of just how much I love it through the latest screen adaptation of it. BBC produced it and aired it in the UK over Christmas, and PBS just showed it in two consecutive weekends this month here in the US. I’ve read quite a bit of criticism of it online, but I honestly don’t know what they’re talking about. I don’t think I expected it, but here it is… 

This is the best version of Little Women I’ve seen. 

The production is beautiful in its sweet simplicity, the cast is endearing, and the tone of the writing strikes a lovely balance between serious yet hopeful, realistic yet heartwarming. It has all the charm and beauty that makes the novel so loved, yet also doesn’t shy away from the growing pains and losses that the March sisters endure as they go from girls to women. Both the 1949 version with June Allyson and the 1994 one with Winona Ryder were staples of my childhood, but I was ready for another take on this story when I heard BBC was adapting it. I really applaud the writer Heidi Thomas for a lovely screen translation of this story that adhered to Alcott's novel better than either of those previous versions. A three-hour runtime was a definite advantage at the outset and she made the most of it by including many plot points that had been left out of the other adaptations and by more fully developing the characters. Here are a few categories of aspects about this version that have made it my new favorite.

Kathryn Newton as Amy, Willa Fitzgerald as Meg, Annes Elwy as Beth, and Maya Hawke as Jo in BBC's Little Women
Photo Credit: Masterpiece PBS on Facebook


Development and Timeline Aspects

First, I appreciate that in this version, all four sisters are treated with equal worth in the beginning and then the story gradually becomes more about Jo. This mirrors the trajectory of the book very well. Previous adaptations brought Jo to the forefront at the beginning, as that was likely an easy way to deal with time constraints. But the story belongs to all four of them at the beginning, and then Jo becomes the clear protagonist by the end. I appreciated the screen time that the other sisters were given in this adaptation. 

Next, the order of events is much more accurately captured here, and a few seemingly smaller, yet significant, plot items that were omitted from previous versions were kept in. The Christmas dinner that Mr. Laurence sends over after he hears that they gave their breakfast to the Hummels, Beth's early shyness to go visit Mr. Laurence to play his piano, the snow maiden that Jo and Amy and Laurie build for Beth after her initial illness, and Laurie's conversation with his grandfather after Jo's rejection are some sweet, beautiful bits included this version that made me very happy. I also appreciated that the long separation in the middle of Meg and John Brooke's engagement while John fought in the war for a period was properly acknowledged. And during the sequence that notes this, there’s a positively exquisite rendition of "Land O' the Leal" sung in voiceover that brings ALL the feels. 

I also really enjoyed how much more character development was given to Mr. March than I would have expected since he had very little in the 1949 and the 1994 versions. We see snippets of his time away at war, and he has many conversations with Jo in the latter half of the runtime. I especially loved a scene they have together after Beth's death in which Jo feels paralyzed by grief, and her father tells her she needs to write again. And on that note, the scenes surrounding Beth's death were by far the most poignant interpretation of that storyline I've seen. Jo's seaside trip with Beth was included this time and I was so glad – the scene on the beach where Beth confides that she's slipping away is as raw and emotional as it's believable. Annes Elwy's portrayal of Beth's quiet strength and gentle dignity is beautiful.
 

Dylan Baker and Maya Hawke as Mr. March and Jo
Photo Credit: Masterpiece PBS on Facebook


Laurie and Amy and Jo

You knew this was coming because it always does. But, significantly, I honestly thought this version captured Laurie's relationships with both Jo and Amy in total respect of the book. Two detailed points:

  • Contrary to popular opinion, I have always agreed with Louisa May Alcott's decision to marry Laurie to Amy. However, the creators of the 1994 movie seemed to agree with many fans and perhaps tried to make their feelings known by giving Jo and Laurie a romantic connection for as long as they could before they just had to follow the book. Winona Ryder and Christian Bale did indeed have sizzling chemistry at times, so Jo's rejection could have understandably appeared off-kilter and confusing for some viewers. What's more, the order of events was changed by placing his proposal before her time in New York. Not so in this new version. Maya Hawke and Jonah Hauer-King have a heartfelt but clearly platonic connection from the get-go, and like the novel, it's obvious that Jo has a maturity beyond her years much earlier than Laurie does. From her perspective, he's always been her brother and when he tries to turn their relationship into something else (which he does multiple times before he actually proposes), she finds it incredibly awkward and unhelpful. And also like the novel, Jo's motive for going to New York is to put space between herself and Laurie in hopes that he’ll realize they're not suited before he does something rash like proposing, rather than trying to get away from him after he proposes.
  • All of that said, I honestly believe that Alcott intended for Laurie and Amy to be together from the beginning. The seeds are planted when he visits her every day during her extended stay with Aunt March while Beth fights her first illness. This version gives more screen time to those interactions. There's an absolutely wonderful scene that's also in the novel in which Amy writes out her "will" and asks Laurie to approve it. In this moment, they begin to share confidences and fears. Their time together in Europe is also well-handled in this adaptation. After the initial catch-up, Laurie is obviously struck by how sophisticated, thoughtful, and intelligent Amy has become, and later, when they've received news of Beth's death, they have a moving scene together where Laurie makes clear to Amy that he won't leave her to grieve alone. It's understood that they spend a lot of time together after this, so their subsequent marriage is the natural progression.
     
Jonah Hauer-King and Kathryn Newton as Laurie and Amy
Photo Credit: Masterpiece PBS on Facebook

A Brilliant Casting Choice 

And finally, I think one of the most noteworthy casting and characterization decisions for this adaptation was in Emily Watson as Marmee and the writing for her. The screen time devoted to her and Emily Watson's performance made me realize how much material related to Marmee has been skipped over in previous adaptations, and it was honestly their loss. This version gives her amazing depth and allows us to see her in a more human and relatable light. She has many more scenes that are directly from the book and that reveal who she is as a person – a deeply kind and generous woman who also sometimes feels the weight of the world on her shoulders. And it’s only natural that she would because at first, she's holding down the home front while her husband is away at war, and later, she experiences many normal pains of motherhood in seeing her children grow up and become independent. Here are a few of the "Marmee scenes" in this version that I loved: 
  • After Amy breaks through the ice, Jo pours out her fears of never being able to govern her tongue or temper to Marmee. Marmee assures Jo that she too has an awful temper and has been working for 40 years to control it.
  • Marmee comes into the bedroom where the girls are getting ready for Meg's wedding, and the four of them strike a pose as they giggle excitedly. Marmee is clearly overcome for a moment at how beautiful and grown-up her girls have become.
  • As Jo becomes concerned over Laurie’s attempts to turn their friendship into romance, she confides to Marmee that she must get away for a while because she knows Laurie will only ever be a brother to her. Marmee assures Jo that her instincts are correct in this area and says that she too has always felt that Jo and Laurie are too much alike to get on as a married couple.
  • When Beth tells Marmee that she's sick and won't recover, Marmee makes a quick exit to cry. Jo follows, and Marmee breaks down in Jo's arms. Cue my own waterworks opening up. 
Emily Watson as Marmee with her girls
Photo Credit: Entertainment Weekly


Are you convinced yet? I certainly hope so. This adaptation was good for my heart and made me feel all the nostalgia for girlhood. And to its credit, it has made me want to pick up the book again before too long. Thank you to all who made this story come alive again so beautifully for me. And thank you again to Little Women itself for reminding me of the beauty of womanhood in all its joys, pains, progressions, and turns. 
Photo Credit: Wallpapers Wide
Every two years, we’re treated to the epic talent and competition that comprise the Olympics, and I’m a huge fan. I love the summer and winter games alike and follow a few sports from each pretty closely. Whether it’s this seemingly magical flipping from the gymnasts, this incredible artistry from ice dancing and ice skating, or this superhuman speed in the pool, we can all agree that the Olympics showcase truly admirable skill that’s worth noticing.

So, I’ve been enjoying the Rio games over the past week or so, and the athletes are wildly impressive as usual, and it’s also offered a nice reprieve in a way. It’s fun to see the Olympics all over the news for a little while instead of violence, terrorism, and politics, and they also get me hyped in a good way. Since the games are concluding soon, I started thinking about inspirational sports stories that would fit well with the Olympic time of year and make the hype last a little longer! These are some of my favorites here as well as a few that are on my to-do list. Let me know what you think! 

To Watch

The Blind Side 
Who doesn’t love Sandra Bullock as Leigh Anne Tuohy, I wanna know? She truly shines as this well-known, successful mom and designer who took in Michael Oher, a young man who was born in the Memphis projects and spent most of his childhood in foster care. Leigh Anne and her husband Sean adopted Michael during his late teens and encouraged his unique gifting in football, eventually seeing him play in college and professionally. 

42 
A masterfully told account of Jackie Robinson, the first African American man to play professional baseball. Harrison Ford turns in a particularly quality performance as Jackie’s team manager. The film is thoughtful, honest, emotional, humorous, and addresses difficult content with excellence. 

Cinderella Man 
One of my favorite movies, and probably my all-time favorite inspirational sports film. James J. Braddock was a successful professional boxer in the 1920s, but a hand injury and the Great Depression threatened his career, as the movie so poignantly tells. As the film unfolds, uncertainty and poverty become new normals for James and his wife Mae and their three children. But the Braddocks cling to perseverance and family unity even when the odds are sharply against them. Yes, this is a story about a man who made a remarkable comeback and left a mark on professional boxing, but it’s also a film about hardship, courage, and how family love can sustain the human spirit through incredible difficulty. Russell Crowe and Renée Zellweger are true joys to watch as James and Mae.

To Read

The Boys in the Boat by Daniel James Brown 
This is a book I’ve mentioned before (it made my list of good book club picks!) and will likely keep mentioning, as I now consider it one of my favorite books ever. A riveting account of the nine-man American rowing team at the 1936 Berlin Olympics, The Boys in the Boat is a true underdog story with spirit and suspense. The nine boys on the team were from the University of Washington in Seattle and entered the Olympics with many factors against them, not to mention that these particular Olympics were staged for Nazi propaganda. You will cry and cheer from your reading spot as you see the courage and incredible teamwork on display through these guys. 

For the Glory by Duncan Hamilton 
One of my current reads and I’m loving it! Most of us know Eric Liddell from the film Chariots of Fire – he was a remarkably fast runner known as the “Flying Scotsman,” and he shocked the world when he withdrew from his best event in the 1924 Olympics because it interfered with Sunday worship. He further stunned audiences when he won gold in an event in which he had considerably less skill. But what the movie lacks this book brings to light – after his Olympic success, Liddell bypassed opportunities for fame and money and served as a missionary in China for the rest of his life. Even in his final years in a Japanese internment camp, he was known for his kindness, prayerful attitude, and sacrificial service to those around him. I’m looking forward to better “knowing” this Eric Liddell through the pages of this book. 

Greater than Gold by David Boudia 
On my to-read list! This one came out just this month to tie in with the Rio games; current Olympic diver David Boudia shares his personal testimony in it. This is his third time to represent the USA at the Olympics, and what I’ve read of his story so far is equally encouraging and challenging. He shares in detail in this book how he used to dive for fame, human praise, and pride in himself. But he came to know Jesus after the 2008 Beijing games, and that has radically transformed his motivation and focus in diving. I can’t wait to read his story in full. Check out this interview for a taste, and watch David and his teammate Steele Johnson in the individual diving events tonight, tomorrow, and Saturday during NBC’s prime time! 

What are your favorite inspirational sports stories? Have you been enjoying the Rio Olympics? What have been your favorite parts to watch? I'd love to hear in comments!
I recently posted on the importance of history and now want to offer tangible suggestions as a follow-up! Before you roll your eyes, please at least read my thoughts first. Fair enough? I hope so, because I only want to be a helpful resource if history is a struggle for you! As I mentioned before, history cannot be limited to a few class lectures or tests. There are myriads of enjoyable ways to learn it, so I now have a few of my favorite historically informative books and movies to share, listed by historical category. Let me know what you think in the comments! 

American Roots

National Treasure (2004): 
Wasn’t this movie all the rage when I was in high school? Many call it the only decent Nicolas Cage movie, but whether that’s true or not, I know it’s a fast-paced, straightforward adventure flick with more useful American history packed in than many textbooks can boast. Mysteries, car chases, betrayals, escapes, and riddles abound, and you’ll come out almost certainly more educated.
Diane Kruger as Abigail Chase and Nicolas Cage as Ben Gates in National Treasure
Photo Credit: Entertainment Wallpaper

Little House on the Prairie series by Laura Ingalls Wilder:
Set in the days of pioneers and covered wagons, this classic series enchanted me when I was a child and made life on the wilderness frontier appear fun. I’ve realized that it’s nice to not have to fight off bears and swarms of bees in everyday life, but these books do demand respect for the early settlers who paved the way for an inhabitable America. Their themes of family, love, friendship, and loyalty also ring true with every new generation who reads them.
The British Empire and Monarchy

Amazing Grace (2006): 
This may have been one of the first movies that drew me to England’s history and culture. It recounts highlights on William Wilberforce, a leader in Parliament and the driving force behind abolishing the African slave trade throughout the British Empire. His work in the late 1700s and early 1800s was largely responsible for awakening the nation to the evils of slavery, and we clearly still see his impact today. This film is just as convicting and inspiring as it is fascinating, and you will be better for watching it.
Ioan Gruffudd as William Wilberforce in Amazing Grace
Photo Credit: Amazing Grace Movie

The Young Victoria (2009): 
A glimpse into the early years of England’s beloved youthful monarch, The Young Victoria focuses on Queen Victoria’s formative days on the throne, which she ascended at the tender age of 18. Her romance with Prince Albert and the unrest she caused among her people early in her reign feature heavily, and this gorgeous production makes it all a delight to watch. The cast and costumes sparkle brilliantly.
Emily Blunt as Queen Victoria and Rupert Friend as Prince Albert in The Young Victoria
Photo Credit: Fanpop

World War I

A Hobbit, a Wardrobe, and a Great War by Joseph Loconte: 
More is coming soon on this book – it’s a new favorite! As the title infers, J.R.R. Tolkien and C.S. Lewis are its primary subjects, and it emphasizes their experiences in trench warfare during World War I. It irrevocably changed them, influencing their famous writings more than many realize. Not only does this book offer an interesting perspective on these authors, but it also gives a necessary look at World War I itself and the cultural ideologies that took hold because of it, which in turn impacted Lewis and Tolkien’s worldviews as literature professors.







Downton Abbey
: 

Because what else? :) Season 2 particularly focuses on World War I, showing how vast estates and aristocratic families faced massive adaptations to their ways of life during the war years. The Downton house is converted to a convalescent home, the young men fight in the trenches, and women who had never worked before eagerly seek ways to be useful in the absence of men on the home side. The war is a turning point in Downton Abbey, for the social and political changes of its aftermath affect everyone from Lord Grantham to the maids below stairs.
Photo Credit:Sallan's Corner
World War II

The Imitation Game (2014): 
Enigma. The word stirs frustration in every government fighting Germany in World War II. It refers to Germany’s unmatched encryption machine that orchestrates communication between military units. All say it’s unbreakable, but mathematician Alan Turing is less convinced. What if the answer is just a smarter machine? So begins his vision for a digital computing device that can break Enigma’s messages instantly. Fellow decoders support him tirelessly, and their work not only saves millions of lives, but also forms the groundwork for Alan Turing’s machines that would evolve into what we now call computers. This is one of my very favorite historical dramas. It shows a lesser-known side of the war. Those involved in it fought with their pencils, brains, and puzzle-solving skills, but their roles also proved to be of paramount importance to the Nazis’ defeat.
Keira Knightley as Joan Clarke, Matthew Beard as Peter Hilton, Benedict Cumberbatch as Alan Turing, Matthew Goode as Hugh Alexander, and Allen Leech as John Cairncross in The Imitation Game
Photo Credit: Movie Wallpapers 101

The Nightingale by Kristin Hannah: 
A harrowing look at the Nazi occupation of France, this book will inform, force self-examination, and break your heart all at once. It focuses on two sisters in the thick of the Nazi regime, and they both face choices they never wanted or imagined. One fights from her home while the other joins the undercover French resistance, and both are heroes in their own way. This book is heavy, but needed. (Read my full review here)









Unbroken by Laura Hillenbrand: 
One of my favorite books I read in 2015, Unbroken tells the incredible true story of Louis Zamperini, a talented Olympic athlete and then WWII bomber pilot. His plane crashed in the Pacific Ocean, and then he and the two other survivors floated on a raft for over a month. They fought off sharks, caught fish, and saved rainwater to survive. They reached land at long last only to find it was Japan, where Louis became a prisoner of war for two years. This book is a true achievement. It reveals the horrors of war and suffering without apology, but weaves in redemption and hope at the same time. We need to see both. 






So, as mentioned, this only scratches the surface, but all of these are excellent and mean a lot to me personally. A few honorable mentions go to the Mark of the Lion trilogy by Francine Rivers, Seven Men and Seven Women, both by Eric Metaxas, and the 2010 movie The King’s Speech. What are your favorite historical fiction books, historical biographies, and historical films? Which of these have you seen and read? I’d love to hear!



*I do not own the rights to the photos in this post*
 As you likely know, I love a good historical drama or historical fiction book. Many of my favorite stories hearken back to a bygone era and portray the vast differences between then and now. Stories set in a long-ago time period encompass much of my reading and watching life, and I’ve only recently realized how necessary this is for me. I spend a lot of time thinking and talking about why stories matter, but lately, I’ve been realizing that history itself is also just as important. Stick with me, please. Just hear me out and give it a thought, maybe? That’s all I ask. 

History can have a bad rap. So many people I meet scoff and roll their eyes when history arises in conversation. I hear people say it’s pointless, boring, or unusable, and I honestly want to cry when I hear such things. If you’re prone to this kind of opinion, will you please try to lay aside that notion for a moment? More than likely, you were never taught history in an engaging way. You may not have been told that events of the past have everything to do with the way you now live and with the worldview to which you now ascribe. And perhaps most tragically, you might not have been told that the study of history serves as an excellent antidote to pride and selfishness, and it can also help lead to a greater knowledge and affection for the God who has written it. 

First of all, history is important because it is God’s doing. History = His story. When we look back into ages gone by, we are meant to see marks of His guidance, sovereignty, and faithfulness all over it. Consider how many times in the Old Testament Israel’s leaders recited Israel’s own history to the people and charged them to remember. How many times did God Himself tell the people to remember and go forward with it in their hearts? How many times did Jesus refer back to Israel’s history and explain how it pointed to Himself? We are commanded to combat doubt, fear, and uncertainty by looking back and remembering (Psalm 77). He has been faithful in the past, so we can go forward in hope.


And second, history is important because it demands humility of us and cultivates humility in us. Looking back requires mentally stepping out of our own time and considering a different viewpoint. It requires admitting that the present is not all there is, and we need that. I’ve been realizing that it is frightfully arrogant and selfish to believe that our current era has all we need and there is nothing to learn from the past. We are not meant to sit in our own personal bubble of time and space without seeking out knowledge of other times and places. To put it bluntly, history did not begin on your birthday or on my birthday, and to act as such by dismissing the lives of those who have gone before us reeks of ignorance and conceit. I’m not saying we all should become history buffs and memorize every country’s historical timeline. History professors will remain their own breed, and that’s completely fine. But I am saying that we have an obligation to preserve the memory of those who came before us and to continue learning from them. Just like all cultures should learn from one another, every new time period should learn from the others before it. Eric Metaxas expresses this profoundly in his excellent book, Seven Women: 

“We must be honest enough to recognize that each era cannot help having a pinched, parochial view of things, and of course the largest part of that parochialism is that each era thinks it is not parochial at all. Each era has the fatal hubris to believe that it has once and for all climbed to the top of the mountain and can see everything as it is, from the highest and most objective vantage point possible. But to assert that ours is the only blinker-less view of things is to blither fatuousness. We need to delve into the past to know that we have not progressed to any point of perfection and objectivity…The Bible says we are to humble ourselves, and in reading the stories of great men and women from the past, we inevitably do just that. But in humbling ourselves in that way we ironically gain a far greater objectivity and a far better vantage point from which to see things.” 

Well said, sir. And Eric Metaxas is only one of many authors who have done us the service of preserving the stories of historical men and women from whom we can learn much. As previously mentioned, I’m sorry if history was presented to you as a chore or necessary evil as you grew up. History is not meant to be confined to a class lecture or a few tests for which to regurgitate random facts. It is something that you can constantly learn in many enjoyable ways. I’ve learned more about World War I and the Roaring ’20s from Downton Abbey than I ever did from a textbook, and a few tours of Washington D.C. and Virginia have made me marvel at God’s faithfulness throughout the founding of the United States. Read, watch, travel, and learn, my friends. There will never be a shortage of material. Hit me up if you need suggestions that are fun and informative! As usual, I think stories help a lot :)


Have you struggled to appreciate history before? What historical settings do you enjoy in books or movies? What are your favorite historical fiction works? I’d love to hear!
Jane Austen’s novels are classics, but they’re the kind of classics that people want to see remade over and over. I’m always curious to see who will step up to the plate next and how a new director will interpret her work. That said, I thought it’d be fun to share a list of my favorite Austen screen adaptations. Since it’d be difficult to put them in an order, I’ve listed them by book alphabetically. So here’s my take on the best Austen film adaptations, just in time for cooler weather when it’ll be ideal to curl up and watch them with a hot cup of tea. 

Emma 
Favorite: BBC 2009 
Two words: Romola Garai. She’s my favorite Emma Woodhouse by a long shot. Not only is she beautiful and perfect in looks for the role, but she also brings the right mixture of lively endearment and vain overconfidence to the character. She’s instantly likable, but it’s also easy to see when she’s in the wrong. In contrast, I found Gwyneth Paltrow rather annoying in the popular 1996 Miramax Films version. In this one, Jonny Lee Miller also rounds it out as an excellent Mr. Knightley – he’s good-looking and compassionate, but pulls off dry humor splendidly too. Mr. Knightley’s scolding of Emma on Box Hill really stands out in this version, and it’s just as plausible as it’s gut-wrenching. It makes me cringe for Emma every time! Another advantage of this adaptation is how well it delves into Frank Churchill and Jane Fairfax. They’re more major characters than in previous versions, and we see their parts in Emma’s development more fully. 
Romola Garai as Emma Woodhouse
{Photo Credit: My Austen Dream World}

Honorable Mention: BBC 1996
Kate Beckinsale and Mark Strong are a fabulous Emma and Knightley, and this is a great version if you don’t want to commit the longer time length for the 2009 one. The Frank Churchill in this one is a bit too perky and smooth for me – you can almost detect insincerity early on. But you also begin to suspect earlier that he and Jane Fairfax have a secret than you do in other versions, and that’s a creative angle I like. The quality of this version perhaps isn’t as crisp as others, but it’s still highly enjoyable, and I’d pull it out any day. And this Mr. Knightley’s quip, “We are not so much brother and sister as to make it improper” will make your heart turn over every time! 
Kate Beckinsale as Emma Woodhouse
{Photo Credit: The Jane Austen Film Club}

Mansfield Park
Austen fans are still awaiting a screen adaptation of Mansfield Park that does justice to the book. Neither current version is worth watching for a strong film interpretation of the book. But for what it’s worth, I watched both close together after I’d read the book and decided fairly quickly that I preferred the 1999 Miramax Films version. Though it differs significantly from the book, it’s a good movie in its own way. First, as I mentioned in a previous post, the opening credits say that it’s based on the novel and Jane Austen’s personal letters and diaries. With that in mind, I was able to just enjoy the movie for what it was, and even though it differs from the book, Austen’s humor and creativity are still very present. Second, it’s an all-around stronger movie. I found the cast much more believable in this one than in the 2007 BBC version. Though that one’s more faithful to the book, the cast falls flat and the story doesn’t flow as well. Frances O’Connor as Fanny in the 1999 version is far more likable and layered to me than Billie Piper, and Jonny Lee Miller (yes, him again; he’s a convincing Austen hero apparently) opposite Frances O’Connor also makes a better Edmund. Their chemistry is sweet and effortless, especially in a wonderful dance during the ball scene. The story also concludes more satisfyingly in the early version. In the 2007 version, Edmund very suddenly declares his love to Fanny in a hurried and rather awkward manner. Austen’s tone is missing, as I can’t picture one of her heroes confessing his love with nothing but an intense, wild-eyed, “I’m sorry! I was blind!” In the 1999 version, the end comes in a sweet scene on a garden bench, where Edmund and Fanny sit as they have many times before, and it’s clear that Fanny has waited patiently in this comfortable companionship for him to realize his feelings. Their words are still simple, but carry the emotional weight you’d expect of Austen’s original dialogue. 
Frances O'Connor as Fanny Price
{Photo Credit: Becoming Jane}

Northanger Abbey 
The 2007 BBC movie is the only well-known adaptation of this book, and it’s a winner. I’d love to see it made again, but I’m not sure who could top JJ Feild as Henry Tilney for me. His charming smirk gives all the feels every time! Felicity Jones as Catherine Morland brings the necessary freshness, youthfulness, and innocence that the heroine requires, and Carey Mulligan as Isabella Thorpe is scandalous to perfection with her loud laughter and sly, flirtatious glances. This adaptation captures the essence of the book without caveat and is altogether charming. It’s perhaps a bit hurried, and the quality isn’t the very best, but those things are honestly easy to forgive as you watch. JJ Feild and Felicity Jones are marvelous together, and the ending sequence is positively giggle-worthy in its happy sweetness. 
JJ Feild and Felicity Jones as Henry Tilney and Catherine Morland
{Photo Credit: FanPop}

Persuasion
Upfront confession: I still have yet to see the 1995 BBC version that so many fans swear by, and I’m honestly a bit hesitant to because Ciarán Hinds just does not look like a Captain Wentworth to me. I know I need to give it a try, but it may take me some time yet ;) And I am very content with the 2007 BBC version for now and highly recommend it. Sally Hawkins is appropriately pretty and sensible as Anne Elliot, and her mannerisms demonstrate the character’s thoughtful, kind nature with quiet dignity. And can we talk about Rupert Penry-Jones as Wentworth? Fetch me the smelling salts if you please! That smile and that voice! And throughout the movie, you see his cool, stiff manner slowly give way to an open gentleness that’s swoon-worthy indeed. The only real drawbacks of this film are near the end. I’m one of many who concur that Anne’s breathless sprint through Bath is out of character and then resolves in probably the worst kissing scene in the history of movies. But the very final scene where Captain Wentworth surprises her with that wonderful wedding gift wraps the film so pleasingly that you can still sigh contentedly as the credits roll. 
Rupert Penry-Jones and Sally Hawkins as Captain Wentworth and Anne Elliot
{Photo Credit: Fiktiviteter}

Pride and Prejudice 
Oh, Pride and Prejudice. The generally most beloved of Jane Austen’s novels and dear to so many hearts. Therefore, its film versions are subject to stricter scrutiny. I’ve said before that I’m personally partial to the 2005 Focus Features movie with Keira Knightley and Matthew Macfadyen, unlike so many who would die in loyalty to the 6-hour BBC miniseries that stars Colin Firth and Jennifer Ehle. Both of these versions are very good, but the 2005 movie has a special place in my heart. It introduced me to Pride and Prejudice and to Jane Austen herself, for that matter. And more specifically, its production quality is breathtaking and I think it has a much stronger cast. The sisters are appropriately young and girlish, whereas the miniseries has an older cast – one of its major weaknesses to me. And in the new one, Donald Sutherland is a fabulously sarcastic Mr. Bennet, Judi Dench is perfectly regal and snobbish as Lady Catherine, and Keira Knightley and Matthew Macfadyen have amazingly believable and sizzling chemistry. However, there are also advantages to the 1995 version that the 2005 movie can’t capture. The longer time length allows for the characters to flesh out more and for the story to develop with details that help the audience appreciate every plot line. And Colin Firth certainly has the Darcy arrogance down well. Both versions are very good and should be appreciated in their own way. So many people seem to think they have to choose one or the other, but I really don’t think you do! They’re different types of films and ought to be commended in different ways. When forced to choose, I’ll pick the 2005 movie, but I can enjoy both of them any day. Click here to read my detailed comparison of these two versions! 
I really like the fresh girlishness of this shot from the 2005 movie. From left to right: Brenda Blethyn as Mrs. Bennet, Rosamund Pike as Jane, Carey Mulligan as Kitty, Talulah Riley as Mary, Keira Knightley as Elizabeth, and Jena Malone as Lydia
{Photo Credit: FanPop}

Sense and Sensibility 
Favorite: BBC 2008 
I feel like this is a hidden gem among Austen adaptations. I’m surprised at how many Austen fans I meet who have never seen it because it’s absolutely lovely. It’s admirably faithful to the novel, and the lush, seaside scenery is beautiful to watch. Hattie Morahan as Elinor and Charity Wakefield as Marianne are both cast to perfection – they capture the opposite personalities wonderfully but also clearly portray the sisterly love that keeps them close through the ups and downs of the story. And of course, I couldn’t go without giving a nod to Dan Stevens as Edward. I actually saw him in this before Downton Abbey shot him to stardom, and I liked him immediately. His rainy log-splitting scene is one of a few aspects that gives this version a more emotional (read: sexy) feel than the early adaptation, and his cheerfulness, thoughtfulness, and ongoing struggle between true wants and honor make the character appropriately layered and enjoyable. I also like this version’s characterization of Colonel Brandon much better than in the 1995 version. We see more of him and understand that he’s a principal character before Willoughby arrives, whereas he felt more like a side character to me in the 1995 version. And his military heroism is shown in a fantastic dueling scene between him and Willoughby. If you haven’t seen this version, do yourself a favor and watch it now! 
Hattie Morahan and Charity Wakefield as Elinor and Marianne Dashwood
{Photo Credit: FanPop}

Honorable Mention: Columbia Pictures 1995 
This version is a classic, though it’s not the most faithful adaptation. One scene that I decidedly miss when I watch it now is Willoughby’s “apology” when Marianne is ill. Elinor’s telling off is so good in the 2008 version that I don’t really like the story without it now. And Hugh Grant’s Edward is a bit awkward, especially since Dan Stevens does it so well in the 2008 version. But it’s still a beautiful film with fabulous music and a strong script, courtesy of Emma Thompson of course, who also plays a convincing Elinor. But the crowning glory of this version for me is Kate Winslet. Her Marianne has all the beauty, vivacity, and charm that heart could wish for. She’s truly a delight to watch in every scene, and she makes the movie for me. 
Emma Thompson as Elinor and Kate Winslet as Marianne
{Photo Credit: Lazy Girls Info}
So there you have it! My list of the best Austen film adaptations. I’d love to hear what your favorites are or any thoughts you have! And here’s hoping we’ll soon have more adaptations to analyze and discuss. 



*I do not own the rights to the photos in this post. All photos used were retrieved from credited Internet sources*
{Fair warnin’: there be big spoilers afoot!}  
You may know from a previous post that I’m a new fan of Masterpiece’s new show, Poldark, which is based on the novels of the same title by Winston Graham. If you saw my Twitter activity during the recent season finale, you likely also thought I’d gone schizophrenic, but rest assured, it was just Poldark. If you’ve also been watching, I know you get me.

With the finale a little over a week gone, I’ve thought a lot about this series. Admittedly, I’d never heard of Poldark before this new TV adaptation premiered, but from what I understand, it’s pretty faithful to the books, and I’m so glad to have found these stories through the show. I do now intend to read the books…maybe all of them before season 2 airs. It might be too tempting. But the season that just finished is based on the first two books in the series, Ross Poldark and Demelza, and I’ve fallen in love with the story. And I think one major character is the primary reason for it all. Her name, of course, is Demelza.

Eleanor Tomlinson as Demelza in Poldark
{Via FanPop}
Demelza Carne Poldark, played brilliantly by Eleanor Tomlinson, is the emotional heart and courage of the story. I’ve rarely encountered a heroine quite as instantly delightful to me as Demelza. She’s tough, intuitive, and deeply compassionate. Her transformation in this first season was one of the most fascinating aspects of the story to me. In the first episode, she’s an abused urchin mistaken for a boy. Ross, offended at the thought of her going home to beatings, takes her in as his kitchen maid, and she not only becomes valuable help for him, but also a comfortable companion. They’re married by the end of episode three, thus beginning her transition from lowly country girl to proper lady as Ross’ wife.

It’s fun, fascinating, humorous, and heart-wrenching to see Demelza journey from abused waif to hardworking handmaiden to the dignified Mistress Poldark and mother of Ross’ child. She’s eager to learn, caring toward others, and has a temper and heartfelt honesty that she never apologizes for. That makes a refreshing contrast between her and Elizabeth Chynoweth Poldark, wife of Ross’ cousin, Francis. Elizabeth is the poster girl for the proper 18th century woman – always classy, ever appropriate, and constantly resorting to duty, even if it goes against her true wants. Demelza does learn propriety, but still never loses her fieriness and isn’t afraid to say what she thinks, even if it goes against the socially acceptable thing.

But Demelza’s softening influence on Ross was one of my favorite things about her. Shortly after they’re married, Ross’ cousin Verity tells Demelza that she’s very happy about the marriage and has great hopes for the good it will do Ross:

“Before he met you, he was broken. Lost. So I was relieved to think he’d found someone to console him – to save him from his loneliness. But now I see it’s more than consolation. You’ve given him hope.” 

Aidan Turner as Ross and Eleanor Tomlinson as Demelza in Poldark
{Via FanPop}
Demelza is hope personified, as one of my favorite bloggers, Laurel Ann Nattress, put it. In a touching scene when Demelza expresses uncertainty about why Ross married her, he tenderly assures her of his love, saying that not only are his feelings sincere, but she’s redeemed him. And in many ways, I think Ross’ rescue of her and giving her a new life instill fresh energy into her qualities that end up changing him most. He just didn’t see at first that he needed her as much as she needed him. Her liveliness, optimism, and childlike joy come exactly when he needs them, for he returns from war a bitter, hardened man. Demelza’s cheerfulness is a balm to his spirit initially, and as their marriage deepens, her steady perseverance in difficult circumstances reminds him to push forward without losing faith. Their difficulties often arise from uncertain finances and the enormous responsibility Ross feels towards his mine workers, and these concerns lead to many exchanges in which Demelza is clearly a voice of wisdom and encouragement for him. These are two of my favorites:

{Discussing their financial situation}

Ross: You must be regretting your marriage to such a destitute rogue.
Demelza: Must I? After what you’ve brought me to? Am I such a great lady now as to forget where I’d be if we’d never met?
Ross: (laughing) Women. None are created equal. Some are never satisfied, some could never be brought so low. And others thumb their noses at adversity and roll up their sleeves.
Demelza: Well, perhaps you wish you’d married a rich lady!
Ross: I’m quite aware of my good fortune, I assure you.
 

{Ross feels responsible for the death of one of his employees} 

Demelza: You did what you could.
Ross: I wonder.
Demelza: Ross, you cannot fight all the world. You can only make your own small corner a fairer place.

Demelza’s hope and compassion are perhaps most poignantly expressed at the end of the season following the tragic death of her and Ross’ baby daughter, Julia. Her grief is undoubtedly deep and painful…honestly, those scenes after Ross breaks the news to her had me undone. Major props to Eleanor Tomlinson for acting her socks off in those heart-wrenching exchanges. They’re very telling moments for both Demelza’s and Ross’ characters. Even in her grief, Demelza sees that from it, there’s a chance for healing her and Ross’ strained relationships with Francis and Elizabeth, and she begs him to make the most of it. Her eagerness to forgive and love is probably never more pointed, offering a powerful challenge to Ross’ skepticism and tendency to condemn more quickly. He hugs her tighter as he says in resignation,

“You make me ashamed. Your heart is so generous. You always see the good in things.”

Ross and Demelza grieve together after Julia's death
{Via FanPop}
Indeed she does. So much so that she even sees that her child's death will not be in vain. I deeply appreciated that about this particular storyline, heartbreaking as it was. And as Demelza’s sweet, hopeful spirit softens Ross throughout their journey together in this first season, we’re also reminded in the audience that even though life can be difficult, we musn’t lose heart. That hope is not empty and love will last. 

 Thanks, Demelza. We need people like you. Here's to your forthcoming heroic efforts to free Ross in season 2! We're all waiting eagerly to see you keep on fighting for him.


*I do not own the rights to the photos in this post. All photos used were retrieved from credited Internet sources*